3.0 out of 5 stars Could Have Been More Fun
Reviewed in the United States on September 24, 2023
Verified Purchase
This was one of those books where you go in wanting to like it because the premise sounds fun. I'm glad I only paid a dollar and some change for it. $15 is outrageous given the quality of the book.
There are some parts that genuinely shine, especially in the last 20 or so pages, which sound like what Tomlinson wanted to write in the first place.
Tomlinson's setting leaves a lot to be desired and is what hurts this book the most, in my opinion. I can take some of the camp and pulp in the Ark. I'm willing to suspend my disbelief a little more than average for the Ark. I'll even ignore a handful of plot holes for the Ark. I'm not willing to smile along as I wonder where the heck I'm supposed to be oriented to in the story.
It took me more than a few pages to understand "football in space" (it wasn't called that). I never got a great idea of how the Ark looked until about 1/3 of the way through the book. A lot of people would give up before then.
The vastness of the Ark doesn't come into view until much later in the book, with the "underground" subplot (there's also an art heist subplot that was a LOT of fun to read). The vastness of the Ark is in PLAY for the entirety of the book, leaving the reader to feel like they're groping around in the dark vacuum of space. The result is a book that wants to emit a cosy vibe, but instead is suffocating.
There were also a couple of instances of casual racism. The Orientalism might make you cringe. Also the idea of causing grand mal seizures as a method of self-defense feels a bit...off? I think the seizures are only for very serious situations, but the fact that they don't have a better way of knocking someone out without potentially disabling or killing them (and leaving a mess of human excrement to clean up after) is hard to believe.
The Ark has apparently had 11 generations of intermixing and yet people are still able to distinguish things like Zimbabwean, or the ever famous "Asian". Humans will lose defining features of ethnicity at 6 - 8 generations. I don't recall there being especially long-lived humans on the Ark--they'd be well over 200 years old.
There are also oddities in the text, such as Tomlinson's insistence on using "span" for "spun", or the interruption of what should have been a very tense moment with a "gay is OK" speech. While I think most of us agree with the premise of the speech, it dissipated any emotion or tension during what was supposed to be a huge reveal.
That wasn't the only place Tomlinson did this. All of the big reveals near the end are ruined by his interjecting, or his rush to get through the payoff of a big reveal. The obvious rush to get through the big reveal is what baffles me most. The vast majority of authors will hurry through the build up because they want the smack of the payoff. Not Tomlinson, though.
There were a few other miscellaneous errors, such as POV shifts that went on for no more than a line or two. Easy mistake to identify and correct that I'm surprised made it into the final product. If he was going for 3rd person omniscient, Tomlinson should have spent far less than in a limited 3rd person POV.
Tomlinson also likes to overuse adverbs, meaning you'll get a lot of tell, not show in the Ark. In fact, outside of describing parts of the Ark, weapons, etc., you don't get a whole lot to go off of. Benson's gorgeous girlfriend arrived at one of their dates look like a snack and all Tomlinson wrote basically amounted to: "she was hot and she had boobs".
Benson as a character manages a good balance. . .kinda. He's neither someone you root for non-stop, nor is he someone you despise. He's a horn dog, a little stuck up, but devoted to his job. In one instance, his horn dog ways nearly lured him into statuatory rape so that was horrifying. Even more horrifying was how Tomlinson gave a better description of this girl than of Benson's girlfriend, Theresa.
Where Tomlinson shines is with his dialogue. Most of it is well-written--even the banter is pleasant to read. His pacing wasn't terrible, although The Ark suffers from a sagging middle like a lot of books.
If you can get it for a buck or two, you can get a couple hours' of cheap, pulpy entertainment. It's a pretty fun read, especially in the last 25% of the book if you can make it there. The plot gets a little out of Tomlinson's control here or there and turns outlandish, so be ready to suspend more disbelief than usual.
This is one of those authors who have a ton of potential, so imagine how sad I was to find out Tomlinson doesn't seem to be writing more books these days.
A solid 3/5.