Where we at with the Nirvana?

G

guest

Guest
Interesting article about the Butch Vig mix of Nevermind. This was how Cobain wanted the album released but Geffen wanted a more overproduced version.

[URL unfurl="true"]https://slate.com/culture/2011/09/nirvana-nevermind-reissue-the-version-of-nirvana-s-album-that-kurt-cobain-loved-best.html[/URL]

[MEDIA=youtube]zudQm-twCI4[/MEDIA]
 

JesseTheGovernor

Access to the Debates
I liked then a lot in my youth. Grew up in that era. But then I grew out of that angsty, teenage rebellion phase so I don’t listen to them too much nowadays. Still enjoy some of their songs.

I also don’t much care if the band members can be faggy or whatever. Most musicians are, and actors, and athletes, and anybody in the public eye. I love the movie Chinatown and Roman Polanski is a pedo. I still like Casino even though de Niro is a total retard of a human. Etc.
 

Riccardo Bosi

welcomes our new overlords
You know how Pacino won the Oscar for Scent of a Woman after all the great shit he did in the 70s, and Scorsese won for The Departed after nearly every other movie he directed that was better? I think the same applies to Grohl for the success he's had with Foo Fighters. Foo Fighters stinks (mediocre at best, anyway) but Grohl does deserve the accolades for Nirvana's success, so if he gets it through being the frontman of a lame band, so be it.

Grohl wasn't originally in Nirvana. Before he was, the band sucked and their debut is abysmal. Grohl reined in Cobain and made sense of his ideas. My favourite song of theirs is Scentless Apprentice. In an interview, Kurt said the riff was Dave's idea and critiqued it first by asking, "isn't this a bit too simplistic/boneheaded?" and Dave had to assure him it would work. Alice In Chains notwithstanding, In Utero defines that decade and genre the best, better than Nevermind.

Grohl also drummed on QOTSA's best album, and it just fucking claps, child.

Same. Alice in Chains has songs that hold up, though. "Rooster" is the better song about the Vietnam war than anything from the '60s.
Jerry Cantrell is the greatest talent out of that period, and he gets no credit for it.
 
They’ve been overplayed to death and for 10 years every band tried to be them, and most did a really poor job. Because of that, people see Nirvana come on the radio and turn it off most of the time. The media took their style and ran it into the ground, which sucks because they were great.
Their Unplugged album is actually my favorite album of all time. Cover to cover gems.
Sure AIC was better, but I think its absurd to say that Nirvana sucks or was never good
 

wbgreen

May St. Mel bless you
Grohl wasn't originally in Nirvana. Before he was, the band sucked and their debut is abysmal. Grohl reined in Cobain and made sense of his ideas.

Grohl worked hard to learn the drums, and other instruments. Cobain came out of that post-punk world where you don't need to actually know how to play an instrument to be in a band (ie It's cool to be lazy. Putting in effort is being sincere, which is something to sneer at.)
 
Top