Favorite Genesis Singer

[bantadant]

Seeing as how we have a celebrity musician in our midst, I wanted to see where he ranks on everyone's list

 

[Kim_Jong_Poon_]

 

[guest]

Ya lookin' at muh gut?
What're ya lookin' at muh gut fer?

 

[BonnieMcFarlaneMe2]

Genesis sucks. No offense, Ray.

 

[ChildSpitTake]

@UnPRePared, comment?

 

[Lamont & Tonelli]

View attachment 145768

Ya lookin' at muh gut?
What're ya lookin' at muh gut fer?

Fuckin mustard tiger.

 

[UnPRePared]

@UnPRePared, comment?

Mine is Peter, as he had the best songs to work with. Not to take away from Phil, his songs were during their most successful run.

I enjoyed some of mine with the band, but there's certain ones I don't enjoy singing. If you listen to the album, you'll know.

 

[Jims_Maroon_Pants]

I like both Peter and Phil

 

['THE NIGGER MAN']

Cherone, the same one that shit the bed with Van Halen?

 

[Cygnus Nana X-1]

Chevy Chase. Ok, he didn't sing but he fawkin' danced.

 

[Jizz]

phil collins rules, sad to see that they have to wheel him out on stage in a wheelchair. he should really just get a badass custom mobility scooter built. i haven't heard ray and i only know gabriel from his 80's stuff like sledgehammer.

phil's solo stuff is great too. awesome cover i timestamped to the climax of the son:

 

[Mr-Wrinkle-Paws]

 

[UnPRePared]

phil collins rules, sad to see that they have to wheel him out on stage in a wheelchair. he should really just get a badass custom mobility scooter built. i haven't heard ray and i only know gabriel from his 80's stuff like sledgehammer.

phil's solo stuff is great too. awesome cover i timestamped to the climax of the son:

There was one guy in here that would go full ham on saying Phil was a cunt, and I'd half joke along with it.

But I'm all seriousness, I feel for the guy and his situation. And he gets a lot of respect from me for doing that tour with his son at the drums. His son is very good.

If you are a fan of Phil, look up early Brand X. That's Phil on the drums and he's amazing.

 

[Sue Lightning]

Mine is Peter, as he had the best songs to work with. Not to take away from Phil, his songs were during their most successful run.

I enjoyed some of mine with the band, but there's certain ones I don't enjoy singing. If you listen to the album, you'll know.

Gabriel is also just a better / more versatile singer IMO.

 

[BootyJuice]

 

[UnPRePared]

Gabriel is also just a better / more versatile singer IMO.

Gabriel said to Phil once, "You can sing better than me, but you can't sing like me." Both a compliment and a challenge to him.


I just wish they had let me sing Supper's Ready even once on that tour, though. Best I got was the opener of it, they claimed they just didn't think it would play.

 

[Smeckler's Powder]

Phil said on Stern that his current favorite band was Dodgy, so gotta at least respect that.

 

[Stent]

Anyone else open threads like this and have to scan back through it to see if you were previously either shitting on Ray or being complimentary? I want to be consistent.